Skip to main content

Texas A&M’s recruiting success is bringing back the oldest criticism in the book

The Aggies are knocking the 2027 cycle out of the park, but it’s causing some fans to trot out the oldest play in the book.
Nov 23, 2024; Auburn, Alabama, USA;  Texas A&M Aggies head coach Mike Elko speaks with a game official during the second quarter against the Auburn Tigers at Jordan-Hare Stadium. Mandatory Credit: John Reed-Imagn Images
Nov 23, 2024; Auburn, Alabama, USA; Texas A&M Aggies head coach Mike Elko speaks with a game official during the second quarter against the Auburn Tigers at Jordan-Hare Stadium. Mandatory Credit: John Reed-Imagn Images | USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Connect

Texas A&M has the top-ranked recruiting class in the entire nation for the 2027 cycle and despite some key defeats, they have put enough distance between themselves and the no. 2 class to nearly be out of reach. The Aggies have identified their top targets and executed a great plan to get them committed and in the boat early on, and it paid off with all the momentum we’ve seen over the last few months.

There are a lot of factors that we can point to that gave rise to the Aggies being so successful this cycle— their early investment in the prospects that they have ended up landing, their excellent recruiting staff, the improvement that Elko has brought to College Station— but there’s one that opposing fans will always have in the chamber and ready to go when the Ags win out for top recruits.

That, of course, is the accusation of prohibitively high NIL commitments to the five-star prospects that the Aggies are landing. This is what was fabricated when the Aggies got the no. 1 class in 2022, and it’s what most are saying now that the Aggies are back in the same spot— something that no one says about other programs, of course.

Texas A&M receiving attention for NIL payouts with no. 1 class firmly in hand

Today, Pete Nakos of On3 reported that Texas A&M is spending north of 10 million dollars on this recruiting class, a report that appears to be based on a comment from an anonymous SEC general manager in a larger article about recruiting in the NIL era.

Of course, while an SEC GM would likely have a better barometer than most for what a team may be spending in order to bring in a recruiting class— this isn’t the hilariously inaccurate 30 million dollar guess that “Sliced Bread” put out back in 2022– there are still manifold reasons to doubt that this is accurate.

First of all, unless this GM works for Texas A&M, he does not have inside knowledge of how the Aggies conduct their business. Kaden Henderson, for example, said that the Aggies’ NIL package was not the biggest he had on the table, and mentioned that was the case for several other recruits as well.

Given that Texas A&M is not the top NIL offer for most of the recruits that they are winning out for, that most likely knocks this estimate down a few pegs. This is especially true if this GM works for a school where lucrative NIL offers are the main play in their recruiting rather than a piece of the whole pitch.

Then, you have the fact that it behooves this SEC GM to put these kinds of ideas out into the public given that exact dollar amounts for these NIL deals are not public. The reasoning is clear: if the common thought is that the Aggies are paying much more than they actually are, then when a prospect sees what Texas A&M is offering him, he may think that it is because the Aggies are undervaluing him— after all, aren’t they a huge spender?

That only helps other teams. When you consider the incentives, it’s clear that this is not a source that should be taken at face value— but it’s exactly what we’ve come to expect when this kind of thing starts happening. Texas A&M fans can rest knowing that Mike Elko has things under control, but this is still frustrating.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations